Join 60,000+ competitive exam aspirants
A question is given followed by two statements numbered (I) and (II). You have to decide whether the data provided in the statements are sufficient to answer the question. Read both the statements carefully and decide the appropriate answer. 5 people - P, Q, X, Y and Z, have an exam on different days of the same week between Monday and Friday. Who has an exam on Thursday? I. Q has an exam on Tuesday. No one has an exam between P and Q. Z has an exam immediately after X. II. X has an exam on one of the days after Q. Only three people have an exam between P and Y 2099
Data in statement II alone is sufficient to answer the question while data in statement I is not
Data in statements I and II together is NOT sufficient to answer the question
Data in statement I alone is sufficient to answer the question while data in statement II is not
Data in statements I and II together (and not statement I alone or statement II alone) is sufficient to answer the question
Data in statements I and II together (and not statement I alone or statement II alone) is sufficient to answer the question
Map the fixed positions first (Q at Tuesday) then test constraints for P and Y to pin down the full schedule.
Map the fixed positions first (Q at Tuesday) then test constraints for P and Y to pin down the full schedule.
Analyze Statement I
Q is Tuesday. No one between P and Q implies P is Monday or Wednesday. Z is immediately after X. Possible scenarios: (Mon: P, Tue: Q, Wed: Y, Thu: X, Fri: Z) or (Mon: X, Tue: Z, Wed: Q, Thu: P, Fri: Y) or (Mon: Y, Tue: Q, Wed: P, Thu: X, Fri: Z). Since multiple arrangements exist, Statement I alone is insufficient.
Analyze Statement II
Three people between P and Y means one is Monday and other is Friday. This leaves Tue, Wed, Thu for Q, X, Z. No info on Q, hence insufficient.
Combining Statements I and II
From I: Q is Tuesday, P is Monday (no one between P and Q). From II: P and Y have 3 people between them, so P is Monday and Y is Friday. Remaining are X and Z. Since Z is immediately after X (from I), they must be Wednesday and Thursday. Therefore, X is Wednesday and Z is Thursday. The person on Thursday is Z. Both are required.
A: Statement II is insufficient as it lacks the relative positions of Q and P. B: The combined data identifies a unique arrangement for all five people. C: Statement I provides multiple valid arrangements for the remaining positions, failing to pinpoint Thursday.
D is correct because combining both statements restricts all variables into a single unique sequence: Mon-P, Tue-Q, Wed-X, Thu-Z, Fri-Y, confirming Z is on Thursday.
In scheduling puzzles, always prioritize the 'fixed' anchor point (e.g., Q on Tuesday) and use it as the origin to test remaining constraints.