Join 60,000+ competitive exam aspirants
Dhritiman tries to extract magnesium from magnesium oxide using carbon. The attempt fails. What is the reason?
Carbon reacts violently with oxygen.
The reaction produces carbon monoxide only.
Magnesium forms a volatile compound with carbon.
Carbon is less reactive than magnesium.
Carbon is less reactive than magnesium.
Magnesium is a highly reactive metal that forms a very stable oxide (MgO). Because magnesium has a much higher affinity for oxygen than carbon does, carbon cannot reduce magnesium oxide at standard metallurgical temperatures.
Magnesium is a highly reactive metal that forms a very stable oxide (MgO). Because magnesium has a much higher affinity for oxygen than carbon does, carbon cannot reduce magnesium oxide at standard metallurgical temperatures.
Think of it like a very possessive magnet: Magnesium is 'in love' with Oxygen and refuses to let go, even if Carbon tries to bribe it to switch partners.
Please Stop Calling Me A Careless Zebra Instead Try Learning How Copper Saves Gold
Mg+21тАЛO2тАЛтЖТMgO тАФ Formation of stable Magnesium oxide
╬ФG=╬ФHтИТT╬ФS тАФ Thermodynamic criteria for spontaneity
In metal extraction, a more reactive element is used to reduce the oxide of a less reactive element. The reactivity series places Magnesium above Carbon. The Gibbs free energy change (DeltaG) for the reaction MgO+CтЖТMg+CO is positive at temperatures practically achievable, meaning the reaction is non-spontaneous. Reduction of magnesium can only be achieved via electrolytic processes, such as the electrolysis of molten magnesium chloride (MgCl2тАЛ).
Magnesium is more reactive than carbon.
Carbon can only reduce oxides of metals lower than it in the reactivity series (e.g., Zn, Fe, Pb).
Highly reactive metals (Mg, Al, Ca) are extracted via electrolysis.
Electrolytic reduction of molten salts
Kroll process for reactive metal production
Magnesium's position in the reactivity series is significantly higher than carbon.
Option A is wrong as the reaction is not thermodynamicially favorable regardless of reactivity speed.
Option B is wrong as the reaction does not proceed at all.
Option C is scientifically incorrect as no such stable volatile compound is formed in this context.
D is correct тАФ Carbon is less reactive than magnesium, meaning it cannot displace magnesium from its oxide.
Remember: Carbon reduction (Smelting) works for metals below Carbon in the reactivity series. Use Electrolysis for anything above (Potassium to Aluminium).