Join 60,000+ competitive exam aspirants
For bulk power transmission over long distance,┬а HVDC transmission is
Economically and technically superior to AC transmission
Not a good alternative to AC transmission
Not economically viable
None of above
Economically and technically superior to AC transmission
HVDC (High Voltage Direct Current) transmission is superior to HVAC for bulk power transmission over very long distances because it eliminates reactive power losses and skin effect issues inherent in AC systems. It is economically viable beyond a specific 'break-even distance' due to lower line costs despite the higher cost of terminal conversion stations.
HVDC (High Voltage Direct Current) transmission is superior to HVAC for bulk power transmission over very long distances because it eliminates reactive power losses and skin effect issues inherent in AC systems. It is economically viable beyond a specific 'break-even distance' due to lower line costs despite the higher cost of terminal conversion stations.
P=XV1тАЛV2тАЛтАЛsin╬┤ тАФ Power transfer capacity in AC lines limited by reactance X and angle ╬┤
CTotalтАЛ=CLineтАЛтЛЕl+CTerminalsтАЛ тАФ Economic model where l is distance; HVDC dominates for large l
In HVDC, AC power is converted to DC at the sending end using a converter station (rectifier) and converted back to AC at the receiving end using an inverter. By eliminating the capacitive charging current and reactive power flow, the transmission line can operate at higher voltages, utilizing insulation more effectively and requiring fewer conductors.
HVDC has no reactive power limitations due to line capacitance.
Skin effect is absent in DC, allowing better utilization of the conductor cross-section.
Smaller right-of-way (ROW) requirements compared to HVAC for same power capacity.
Independent control of active power flow between asynchronous AC systems.
No charging current or reactive power losses
Lower transmission line cost per km
Smaller physical footprint (Right of Way)
Asynchronous interconnection of different frequency grids
Expensive converter stations at both ends
Complex harmonic filtering requirements
Difficult circuit interruption compared to AC
High cost of reactive power compensation (if required)
Long-distance bulk power transmission (e.g., Ultra-High Voltage DC)
Submarine cable links
Interconnection of power grids with different frequencies
Connecting remote renewable energy sources
| Feature | HVAC | HVDC |
|---|---|---|
Reactive Power | Significant losses | Zero |
Converter Cost | Low (Transformers) | High (Converters) |
The 'break-even distance' is typically between 600-800 km for overhead lines and 50-100 km for subsea cables.
Option B is incorrect because HVDC is specifically designed for such applications as a superior alternative to HVAC in terms of stability and efficiency.
Option C is incorrect because despite high terminal costs, long-distance transmission favors HVDC due to reduced line losses and investment.
A is correct тАФ HVDC transmission is technically and economically superior to AC for long-distance bulk power transfer due to the absence of reactive power and skin effect constraints.
Always remember that for short distances, the high cost of conversion equipment makes HVAC the standard choice, but the threshold shifts drastically for undersea cabling.