Join 60,000+ competitive exam aspirants
For the same HP rating and full load speed which of the following motor has poor starting torque?
Series
Shunt
Cumulative compound
Differently compounded
Differently compounded
A differentially compounded DC motor has poor starting torque because the series field flux opposes the shunt field flux at the moment of start. This opposition results in a lower net flux (╬жnetтАЛ=╬жshтАЛтИТ╬жseтАЛ), which directly reduces the starting torque developed by the armature.
A differentially compounded DC motor has poor starting torque because the series field flux opposes the shunt field flux at the moment of start. This opposition results in a lower net flux (╬жnetтАЛ=╬жshтАЛтИТ╬жseтАЛ), which directly reduces the starting torque developed by the armature.
TaтАЛтИЭ╬жZPIaтАЛ/A
╬жnetтАЛ=╬жshтАЛтИТ╬жseтАЛ
In a differentially compounded motor, the series winding is wound to produce flux opposite to the shunt field. Since torque TтИЭ╬жaтАЛIaтАЛ, the reduction in net magnetic flux due to the series field effect significantly diminishes the total torque available at starting conditions when the current is high.
Differential compounding results in a reduction of total field flux.
The starting torque is severely limited as the series field strength is directly proportional to the armature current at start.
This motor type is rarely used due to the risk of torque reversal and instability.
Cumulative compound motors have higher starting torque because fields assist each other.
Useful in specific constant-speed applications where slight speed variation is required
Maintains constant speed under very specific load conditions
Unstable operation as load increases
Risk of speed rising to dangerous levels
Poor starting torque performance
Laboratory research settings
Rare specialized high-precision machinery
| Feature | Cumulative | Differential |
|---|---|---|
Flux Relationship | Additive | Opposing |
Starting Torque | High | Low |
The shunt motor (Option B) has a moderate starting torque. The series motor (Option A) has the highest starting torque.
If the load is too high for a differentially compounded motor, the flux can become so low that the motor may reverse direction or stall.
D is correct тАФ The opposing flux generated by the series winding in a differentially compounded motor reduces the total effective flux, thereby significantly lowering the starting torque.
Always remember that in compound machines, 'cumulative' means flux addition (higher torque) and 'differential' means flux subtraction (lower torque/instability).