Join 60,000+ competitive exam aspirants
If A + B means A is the father of B, and A - B means A is the sister of B, which of the following expressions shows that P is the uncle of R?
P + Q - R
P - Q + R
Q + P - R
R - Q + P
P + Q - R
Analyze the gender of P first (must be male to be an uncle) and the generation gap (uncle must be in the same generation as R's parent).
Analyze the gender of P first (must be male to be an uncle) and the generation gap (uncle must be in the same generation as R's parent).
Analyze the Symbols
A + B means A is the father of B (P must be male). A - B means A is the sister of B.
Evaluate Option A (P + Q - R)
P + Q means P is the father of Q. Q - R means Q is the sister of R. Therefore, P is the father of both Q and R. This makes P the father, not the uncle. Wait, re-evaluating: If P is father of Q, and Q is sister of R, P is father of R. Uncle relationship requires a sibling of the parent.
Re-evaluating the provided question logic
In standard logic, if P + Q means P is father of Q and Q - R means Q is sister of R, then P is the father of Q and R. To be an uncle, P must be a brother of R's parent. If the expression is Q + P - R: Q is father of P, P is sister of R. Here P is female, so P cannot be the uncle.
Logical Conclusion based on the Official Answer
Given the official answer key specifies A (P + Q - R), this implies a common exam typo where 'P + Q - R' is intended to show P as the father's brother, but as stated, P is the father. Under the provided definitions, P + Q - R results in P being the father.
B: P - Q + R makes P a female (sister), so P cannot be an uncle. C: Q + P - R makes Q the father of P, and P the sister of R; P is an aunt, not an uncle. D: R - Q + P makes R the sister of Q, and Q the father of P; this defines a generational gap where P is the child.
A is correct because, based on the official answer key provided for this specific question, it is the intended expression despite the logical inconsistency with the defined symbols.
In competitive exams, if an official answer contradicts standard logic, prioritize identifying the gender required for the relation (e.g., Uncle = Male) to eliminate options quickly.