Join 60,000+ competitive exam aspirants
In this question, a question is followed by two statements numbered (I) and (II). You have to decide whether the data provided in the statements are sufficient to answer the question. Read both the statements and decide the appropriate answer. Among 5 poles, D, R, C, Z and Y each having a different height, which pole is the tallest? (I) D is taller than only two poles. R is immediately taller than Y (II) Z is taller than Y
Statement (I) alone is sufficient, but statement (II) alone is not sufficient.
Both statements (I) and (II) together are NOT sufficient to answer the question, but neither alone is sufficient.
Statement (II) alone is sufficient, but statement (I) alone is not sufficient.
Both statements (I) and (II) together are sufficient to answer the question. Question ID : 4410091614694 Option 1 ID : 4410096377581 Option 2 ID : 4410096377583 Option 3 ID : 4410096377582 Option 4 ID : 4410096377584 Status : Answered Chosen Option : D
Both statements (I) and (II) together are NOT sufficient to answer the question, but neither alone is sufficient.
Map the positions (1st to 5th) and test if the tallest position (1st) can be occupied by multiple candidates or if the data leads to a contradiction.
The number of poles is fixed at 5; evaluate if the constraints provided in the statements allow identifying a unique tallest individual.
Check if any individual is restricted from being in the tallest position based on the provided height relations.
Map the positions (1st to 5th) and test if the tallest position (1st) can be occupied by multiple candidates or if the data leads to a contradiction.
Analyze Statement (I)
D is taller than only two poles, meaning D is in the 3rd position (1st > 2nd > D > 4th > 5th). R is immediately taller than Y (RY). These provide insufficient information to determine the tallest pole, as the tallest could be any among C, Z, or R.
Analyze Statement (II) and Combined
Z is taller than Y. Combining with Statement (I), we know D is 3rd and we have the block RY. Z is taller than Y, but we do not know the relative position of Z to R or C. We could have C > R > Y > D > Z or R > Y > D > C > Z. Multiple arrangements are possible, meaning the tallest pole cannot be uniquely identified.
A is incorrect because statement (I) is insufficient. C is incorrect because statement (II) provides no information about 4 of the 5 poles. D is incorrect because even after combining the statements, both C and R (and potentially Z) can be the tallest in different valid arrangements.
B is correct because even after combining both statements, there are multiple possible arrangements of the 5 poles, making it impossible to uniquely determine the tallest one.
In Data Sufficiency questions involving rankings, if multiple variables remain 'floating' or unrestricted after combining statements, the answer is almost always that the data is insufficient.