Join 60,000+ competitive exam aspirants
Relay coil does not trip. which of the following is not a suitable reason?
Carbonised or burn contact
Battery discharged
Low spring tension
Relay contact not proper
Carbonised or burn contact
Carbonised or burnt contacts cause high contact resistance or open circuits in the relay contact circuit, which leads to failure in closing the trip coil circuit or causes erratic tripping, but it does NOT directly prevent the relay coil itself from becoming energized or failing to trip if the relay operating coil experiences an overcurrent/fault condition. Low spring tension, a discharged battery, or improper relay contacts are directly responsible for relay coil or tripping circuit failure mechanisms.
IS 3231 / IEC 60255
Carbonised or burnt contacts cause high contact resistance or open circuits in the relay contact circuit, which leads to failure in closing the trip coil circuit or causes erratic tripping, but it does NOT directly prevent the relay coil itself from becoming energized or failing to trip if the relay operating coil experiences an overcurrent/fault condition. Low spring tension, a discharged battery, or improper relay contacts are directly responsible for relay coil or tripping circuit failure mechanisms.
FopтАЛ=K1тАЛтЛЕI2тИТK2тАЛ тАФ electromagnetic operating force in induction relay
VbatteryтАЛ<VminтАЛ тАФ causes trip circuit failure
In a protective relay scheme, the relay operating coil senses the fault current from the CT/PT. Upon sensing a fault above the pickup value, the relay contacts close, completing the DC circuit powered by a station battery to energize the Circuit Breaker (CB) trip coil. If the station battery is discharged, no trip current flows. If the spring tension is too low or improper contact movement exists, the relay mechanism fails to operate properly. However, carbonised contacts belong to the secondary tripping circuit (or CB auxiliary circuit) preventing CB trip, but do not explain why a relay coil itself fails to operate/trip when designed.
The relay operating coil requires sufficient current from CT/PT and healthy mechanical restoring spring balance to operate.
A discharged auxiliary battery prevents current flow in the trip coil circuit when the relay contacts close.
Low spring tension alters the pick-up setting and plug setting multiplier (PSM), affecting the tripping mechanism calibration.
Carbonised contacts lead to open circuit or high contact resistance in the circuit breaker trip loop, preventing CB operation rather than causing relay coil non-tripping.
Regular testing ensures battery supply reliability in protection schemes
Proper spring calibration guarantees accurate time-current characteristics
Carbonization of contacts reduces contact conductivity over repeated arc exposures
Discharged battery leads to complete failure of protection system (DC failure)
Substation Protection Schemes
Overcurrent and Earth Fault Protection in Feeders
Generator and Transformer Protection
Option A: Carbonised/burnt contacts affect current conduction through the contacts to the trip coil, but it is not a direct cause of the relay coil itself failing to trip/energize.
Option B: Discharged battery results in lack of DC supply, so trip circuit won't operate.
Option C: Incorrect or low spring tension leads to improper restraint force, preventing designed operating characteristics.
Option D: Improper relay contact alignment or contamination prevents circuit completion.
A is correct тАФ Carbonised or burnt contacts affect contact conductivity to the CB trip coil rather than serving as a reason for relay coil non-operation.
Remember that relay coil actuation depends on AC input (CT/PT) and mechanical restraint (spring/gravity), whereas trip coil actuation depends on DC auxiliary battery supply via relay contacts.