Join 60,000+ competitive exam aspirants
There is a leak at the bottom of a cistern. Due to this it takes 8 hours to fill the cistern. Had there not been a leak, it would have taken one hour less to fill the cistern. How much time does it take for the leak to completely empty the cistern?
56 hours
15 hours
48 hours
5531тАЛ hours
56 hours
Use the formula TleakтАЛ=T2тАЛтИТT1тАЛT1тАЛ├ЧT2тАЛтАЛ where T1тАЛ is the time with the leak (8 hours) and T2тАЛ is the time without the leak (7 hours). Thus, TleakтАЛ=8тИТ78├Ч7тАЛ=56 hours.
Time taken to fill the cistern with leak = 8 hours. Time taken without the leak = 8 - 1 = 7 hours.
TnetтАЛ1тАЛ=TfillтАЛ1тАЛтИТTleakтАЛ1тАЛ
Use the formula TleakтАЛ=T2тАЛтИТT1тАЛT1тАЛ├ЧT2тАЛтАЛ where T1тАЛ is the time with the leak (8 hours) and T2тАЛ is the time without the leak (7 hours). Thus, TleakтАЛ=8тИТ78├Ч7тАЛ=56 hours.
Students often subtract the times incorrectly or treat the leak as adding to the flow rate instead of reducing it.
Define Rates
Let the inlet rate be I and the leak rate be L. The time taken to fill without the leak is 7 hours, so I=1/7 tank/hour. With the leak, the time taken is 8 hours, so IтИТL=1/8 tank/hour.
I=71тАЛ,IтИТL=81тАЛ
Calculate Leak Rate
Substitute I into the second equation: 1/7тИТL=1/8. Rearranging gives L=1/7тИТ1/8.
L=568тИТ7тАЛ=561тАЛ
Final Result
The time required to empty the cistern is the reciprocal of the leak rate: 1/(1/56)=56.
T=56┬аhours
A is correct because the leak reduces the net flow rate such that the effective rate of emptying is 1/56 per hour, resulting in 56 hours to empty.
This is essentially a 'Work and Time' problem in disguise. Remember that leak rate is treated as negative work!