Join 60,000+ competitive exam aspirants
Which of the following materials cannot be used as a moderator?
Deuterium
Graphite
Heavy water
Beryllium
Deuterium
A moderator is a medium used in nuclear reactors to slow down high-speed fast neutrons to thermal energies, thereby increasing the probability of fission. Deuterium itself is an element (isotope of hydrogen); it is the heavy-hydrogen atoms within the molecule of heavy water (D2тАЛO) that function as the moderator, not pure deuterium gas.
A moderator is a medium used in nuclear reactors to slow down high-speed fast neutrons to thermal energies, thereby increasing the probability of fission. Deuterium itself is an element (isotope of hydrogen); it is the heavy-hydrogen atoms within the molecule of heavy water (D2тАЛO) that function as the moderator, not pure deuterium gas.
╬╛=ln(EfтАЛEiтАЛтАЛ) тАФ The average logarithmic energy decrement per collision
╬гsтАЛ=N╧ГsтАЛ тАФ The macroscopic scattering cross-section
Moderators work through the process of elastic scattering. When fast neutrons collide with the nuclei of the moderator material, they transfer kinetic energy to the nucleus, effectively slowing down (thermalizing) until they reach an equilibrium energy level compatible with the surrounding temperature. This is defined by the logarithmic energy decrement factor, which is high for materials with low atomic mass numbers such as Carbon or Deuterium.
A good moderator must have a low atomic mass to maximize energy transfer per collision.
The moderator must have a low neutron absorption cross-section to prevent neutron capture.
Heavy water (D2тАЛO) is one of the most efficient moderators due to its low capture cross-section.
Deuterium is an atom, while the actual engineering material is a compound like D2тАЛO or Graphite (C).
Increases the thermal fission probability
Allows the use of natural uranium as fuel
Can lead to large reactor sizes
May require high-purity materials to prevent parasitic neutron capture
Pressurized Heavy Water Reactors (PHWR)
Graphite-moderated reactors (e.g., RBMK or Magnox)
The question implies that 'Deuterium' (the element) cannot be used in isolation as a practical industrial moderator compared to materials like D2тАЛO or Graphite.
Option B (Graphite), C (Heavy Water), and D (Beryllium) are all globally accepted standard moderator materials.
A is correct тАФ Deuterium is an element, whereas practical engineering moderators are compounds or substances like heavy water or graphite that contain deuterium or carbon atoms.
Always remember the difference between a chemical element and the engineering medium (e.g., Deuterium vs Heavy Water). In exams, focus on materials capable of significant neutron scattering with minimal absorption.