Join 60,000+ competitive exam aspirants
Air will not be the working substance in a
Closed cycle gas turbine
Open cycle gas turbine
Petrol engine
Diesel engine
Closed cycle gas turbine
In a closed-cycle gas turbine, the working fluid is recirculated throughout the system and is never exhausted into the atmosphere. Consequently, any inert gas with favorable thermodynamic properties (such as Helium, Argon, or Carbon Dioxide) can be used instead of air to optimize heat transfer and cycle efficiency.
In a closed-cycle gas turbine, the working fluid is recirculated throughout the system and is never exhausted into the atmosphere. Consequently, any inert gas with favorable thermodynamic properties (such as Helium, Argon, or Carbon Dioxide) can be used instead of air to optimize heat transfer and cycle efficiency.
WnetтАЛ=WtтАЛтИТWcтАЛ тАФ Net work output of the cycle
╬╖thermalтАЛ=1тИТrp(╬│тИТ1)/╬│тАЛ1тАЛ тАФ Ideal efficiency of the Brayton cycle
Unlike open-cycle systems where air is drawn from the atmosphere and discharged, the closed-cycle system utilizes a heat exchanger to transfer energy from an external source to the working fluid. Since the fluid is contained, high-density gases or noble gases are often preferred to reduce the physical size of the turbine blades and compressors while maintaining high power density.
Closed-cycle turbines use external combustion or nuclear heat sources.
Working fluids like Helium have higher thermal conductivity than air, leading to more compact heat exchangers.
Open-cycle systems (like standard petrol/diesel/gas turbines) must use air because the oxygen is required for internal combustion.
Air is generally the working substance in open-cycle systems due to its abundance and ease of disposal.
Higher efficiency at partial loads.
Ability to use low-grade or solid fuels via heat exchangers.
No corrosion or erosion from combustion products.
Requires a large and expensive high-pressure heat exchanger.
Complexity of sealing the working fluid in the loop.
Limited suitability for mobile applications.
Nuclear power plants (HTGRs).
Closed-loop industrial waste heat recovery.
Options B, C, and D describe internal combustion systems where the fuel burns within the fluid, necessitating the use of air (which provides oxygen).
A closed-cycle gas turbine is essentially a Brayton cycle where the heat is added through a wall, removing the dependency on atmospheric air.
A is correct тАФ The closed-cycle gas turbine recirculates its working fluid, allowing for the use of gases other than air, whereas internal combustion engines require oxygen from air.
Always distinguish between internal combustion (requires air) and external combustion (can use any suitable gas) when analyzing thermodynamic cycle questions.