Join 60,000+ competitive exam aspirants
HVDC transmission is preferred to EHV AC because
HVDC terminal equipment are inexpensive
VAR compensation is not required in HVDC
System stability can be improved
Harmonic problem is avoided
System stability can be improved
HVDC transmission is preferred over EHV AC for long-distance power transfer because it decouples the frequency of the two connected AC systems and provides rapid control over power flow. This capability significantly enhances the transient and steady-state stability of the power grid.
HVDC transmission is preferred over EHV AC for long-distance power transfer because it decouples the frequency of the two connected AC systems and provides rapid control over power flow. This capability significantly enhances the transient and steady-state stability of the power grid.
P=XV1тАЛV2тАЛтАЛsin╬┤ тАФ Power transfer equation for AC lines showing dependency on stability angle ╬┤
PDCтАЛ=VdтАЛIdтАЛ тАФ Power flow in HVDC, controllable via firing angle ╬▒ independent of system phase angle
In an HVDC system, the power flow is controlled by adjusting the firing angles of the thyristor valves in the converter stations. This allows for precise and near-instantaneous control of active power, which helps in damping power oscillations and preventing system instability during disturbances. Unlike AC lines, HVDC does not have a power angle limit (P=XV1тАЛV2тАЛтАЛsin╬┤), making it superior for bulk power transmission over long distances or through weak AC ties.
HVDC has no skin effect, leading to better utilization of conductor cross-section.
No charging current issues unlike high-voltage AC cables.
Provides asynchronous interconnection between different AC grids.
Reduces short circuit levels on the connected AC networks.
Improved transient and steady-state stability
Lower transmission losses over long distances
Precise and rapid power flow control
Ability to interconnect asynchronous grids
High cost of converter stations
Generation of significant harmonics requiring expensive filters
Requires reactive power compensation at terminals
Long-distance bulk power transmission
Submarine cable interconnections
Asynchronous grid synchronization
Stabilizing weak AC networks
| Feature | EHV AC | HVDC |
|---|---|---|
Stability limit | Limited by power angle ╬┤ | Not limited by synchronous angle |
Option A is wrong: HVDC terminal equipment is significantly more expensive than AC substations.
Option B is wrong: HVDC converter stations actually consume reactive power and require significant compensation.
Option D is wrong: HVDC generates substantial harmonics, not avoids them; hence harmonic filters are essential.
C is correct тАФ HVDC provides independent control of active power and aids in damping oscillations, thereby improving system stability.
Always remember that while HVDC improves stability, the cost of converter stations is the primary economic trade-off against EHV AC transmission.