Join 60,000+ competitive exam aspirants
In comparison to steam power plants, the gas power plants have
Low initial cost but higher operating cost
High initial cost but low operating cost
Both initial as well operating costs high
Both initial as well as operating costs low
Low initial cost but higher operating cost
Gas power plants have a significantly lower initial capital cost compared to steam power plants because they lack complex sub-systems such as large boilers, coal handling plants, and steam condensers. However, they operate on high-grade fuels like natural gas or distillate oils, which leads to higher running and maintenance costs compared to the lower-cost fuels (like coal) typically used in steam plants.
Gas power plants have a significantly lower initial capital cost compared to steam power plants because they lack complex sub-systems such as large boilers, coal handling plants, and steam condensers. However, they operate on high-grade fuels like natural gas or distillate oils, which leads to higher running and maintenance costs compared to the lower-cost fuels (like coal) typically used in steam plants.
CtotalтАЛ=CfixedтАЛ+CvariableтАЛ тАФ Total cost equation where gas plants emphasize CfixedтАЛ reduction.
Gas power plants operate on the Brayton cycle, involving compression of air, constant-pressure combustion, and expansion in a turbine. The simplicity of this open-cycle system reduces civil work and equipment footprint. Conversely, steam plants operate on the Rankine cycle, which is more complex but utilizes cheaper, lower-quality solid fuels, resulting in different economic trade-offs.
Gas plants utilize the Brayton cycle, while steam plants use the Rankine cycle.
Steam plants are preferred for base load due to cheap fuel (coal).
Gas plants are preferred for peak load due to quick start-up and low capital investment.
Low initial installation cost
Short gestation period
Quick start-up and loading capability
Higher fuel costs
Lower thermal efficiency compared to large-scale combined cycle plants
Dependent on high-quality fuel availability
Peak load power generation
Emergency standby power units
| Feature | Gas Plant | Steam Plant |
|---|---|---|
Initial Cost | Low | High |
Fuel Cost | High | Low |
The thermal efficiency of simple cycle gas plants is typically lower than that of large Rankine cycle steam plants, though Combined Cycle Gas Turbine (CCGT) plants can exceed 60% efficiency.
Option B is incorrect as steam plants generally require massive infrastructure, leading to high capital expenditure.
A is correct тАФ Gas power plants exhibit lower initial capital expenditure due to less complex equipment but face higher operating expenses due to the cost of premium gaseous or liquid fuels.
Always remember that 'Peak Load' plants (like Gas/Hydro) prioritize low initial cost, while 'Base Load' plants (like Coal/Nuclear) prioritize low fuel/operating costs.