Join 60,000+ competitive exam aspirants
_________________ is the disadvantage and _____________________ is the advantage of back e.m.f starter against time delay automatic DC motor starter.
need feedback, accurate control
need setting, accurate control
need setting, not accurate control
need feedback, not accurate control
need feedback, accurate control
In a back e.m.f. starter for a DC motor, the starting resistance is cut out automatically based on the magnitude of the counter electromotive force (EbтАЛ), which directly mirrors motor speed. This requires continuous feedback sensing of EbтАЛ, providing accurate control since resistance is reduced strictly in step with actual motor acceleration rather than on a fixed time interval.
In a back e.m.f. starter for a DC motor, the starting resistance is cut out automatically based on the magnitude of the counter electromotive force (EbтАЛ), which directly mirrors motor speed. This requires continuous feedback sensing of EbтАЛ, providing accurate control since resistance is reduced strictly in step with actual motor acceleration rather than on a fixed time interval.
EbтАЛ=VтИТIaтАЛRaтАЛ тАФ Back e.m.f. relation with terminal voltage and armature drop
EbтАЛ=60A╬жZNPтАЛ тАФ Back e.m.f. equation showing proportionality to speed (EbтАЛтИЭN)
IaтАЛ=RaтАЛ+RstтАЛVтИТEbтАЛтАЛ тАФ Armature current during starting
As the motor accelerates, its back e.m.f. (EbтАЛ=60A╬жZNPтАЛ) increases proportionally with speed (N). A sensitive voltage-sensing relay connected across the armature detects this EbтАЛ; when EbтАЛ reaches a preset safe threshold, the relay energizes to cut out starting resistance. This closed-loop feedback mechanism ensures starting resistance is cut out only when the motor reaches sufficient speed, regardless of load conditions.
Back e.m.f. starter uses feedback voltage across the armature to trigger contactors.
Time delay automatic starters cut out resistance at fixed time intervals regardless of actual motor speed.
The necessity of continuous sensing feedback makes back e.m.f. starters more complex, but guarantees accurate acceleration control.
Provides highly accurate control because resistance cutting depends directly on motor speed/load conditions.
Prevents premature removal of starting resistance under heavy load conditions.
Requires continuous feedback mechanism (voltage sensing circuitry across the armature).
Voltage fluctuations in the supply line can affect relay operation accuracy.
Automatic DC motor control systems where load varies significantly during startup.
Industrial drives requiring precise, feedback-controlled acceleration sequences.
| Feature | Back E.M.F. Starter | Time Delay Starter |
|---|---|---|
Control Mechanism | Senses armature voltage (EbтАЛ) | Fixed timer (dashpot / time-delay relay) |
Feedback Dependency | Requires continuous voltage feedback | Open-loop (No feedback needed) |
Control Accuracy | Accurate (adapts to motor speed/load) | Less accurate (ignores actual motor speed) |
At standstill (N=0), EbтАЛ=0, so full starting resistance (RstтАЛ) is inserted to limit high starting current IaтАЛ.
Option B and C are incorrect because 'need setting' is not the primary disadvantage of back e.m.f. control compared to timer settings.
Option D is incorrect because back e.m.f. control offers accurate (closed-loop) control, not inaccurate control.
A is correct тАФ Back e.m.f. starter needs feedback from the armature circuit to operate, but offers accurate speed-dependent control over time delay starters.
Always remember that back e.m.f. starters are closed-loop (speed/voltage dependent), while time-delay starters are open-loop (time dependent).