Join 60,000+ competitive exam aspirants
Rankine cycle operating between pressure limits of PтВБ and PтВВ has thermal efficiency
Lower than that carnot cycle operating between same pressure limits
Higher than that of carnot cycle operating between same pressure limits
Same as that of carnot cycle operating between same pressure limits
None of above
Higher than that of carnot cycle operating between same pressure limits
The Rankine cycle efficiency is higher than the Carnot cycle efficiency when both operate between the same pressure limits (P1тАЛ and P2тАЛ) because the Carnot cycle is restricted by the temperature limits corresponding to the saturation temperatures at these pressures. In the Rankine cycle, the heat addition process (superheating) occurs at a higher mean effective temperature than the isothermal heat addition of the Carnot cycle, leading to higher cycle efficiency.
The Rankine cycle efficiency is higher than the Carnot cycle efficiency when both operate between the same pressure limits (P1тАЛ and P2тАЛ) because the Carnot cycle is restricted by the temperature limits corresponding to the saturation temperatures at these pressures. In the Rankine cycle, the heat addition process (superheating) occurs at a higher mean effective temperature than the isothermal heat addition of the Carnot cycle, leading to higher cycle efficiency.
╬╖CarnotтАЛ=1тИТThighтАЛTlowтАЛтАЛ тАФ Carnot cycle efficiency based on temperature limits
╬╖RankineтАЛ=QinтАЛWnetтАЛтАЛ тАФ Rankine cycle efficiency based on energy balance
In a Carnot cycle, heat addition happens isothermally at the boiling temperature corresponding to PhighтАЛ. In a Rankine cycle, heat is added as sensible heat during the liquid phase, during phase change at constant pressure, and optionally during superheating. Because superheating allows the average temperature of heat addition to be significantly higher than the saturation temperature at PhighтАЛ, the Rankine cycle overcomes the isothermal constraint of the Carnot cycle for a given pressure range.
The Carnot cycle is the most efficient cycle between two temperature limits.
Pressure limits (P1тАЛ,P2тАЛ) dictate the saturation temperatures (TsatтАЛ), not the cycle's actual operating temperatures.
Rankine cycles utilize superheating, which elevates the average heat addition temperature.
At the same pressure limits, the Carnot cycle is constrained to Tsat,lowтАЛ and Tsat,highтАЛ.
Higher thermal efficiency through superheating
Practical feasibility compared to isothermal heat addition
Requires high-quality steam generators
Material constraints at high superheat temperatures
Thermal power plants
Cogeneration systems
| Feature | Carnot Cycle | Rankine Cycle |
|---|---|---|
Heat Addition Process | Isothermal | Sensible + Latent + Superheat |
This phenomenon is specific to the definition of 'same pressure limits'. If the comparison was made between the same 'temperature limits', the Carnot cycle would always have higher efficiency.
Option B is correct because the Rankine cycle allows for heat addition at temperatures exceeding TsatтАЛ at PhighтАЛ.
B is correct тАФ The Rankine cycle exhibits higher efficiency than a Carnot cycle operating between the same pressure limits due to the increased mean effective temperature of heat addition provided by superheating.
Always distinguish between 'pressure limits' and 'temperature limits' when evaluating thermodynamic cycles, as the comparison results flip depending on which constraints are fixed.