Join 60,000+ competitive exam aspirants
Which of the following metals reacts with very dilute nitric acid to evolve hydrogen gas?
Magnesium
Copper
Iron
Zinc
Copper
Among the options provided, Manganese (Mn) is the only metal that reacts with very dilute nitric acid (approximately 1%) to evolve hydrogen gas. Most other metals, such as Zinc or Iron, typically react with nitric acid to produce oxides of nitrogen because nitric acid is a strong oxidizing agent that oxidizes the produced hydrogen to water.
Among the options provided, Manganese (Mn) is the only metal that reacts with very dilute nitric acid (approximately 1%) to evolve hydrogen gas. Most other metals, such as Zinc or Iron, typically react with nitric acid to produce oxides of nitrogen because nitric acid is a strong oxidizing agent that oxidizes the produced hydrogen to water.
Think of a strong bodyguard (Nitric Acid). Usually, he is so overprotective that he 'catches' any hydrogen (a small, energetic kid) that tries to run away and turns it into water (a stable adult). Only with specific, 'calmer' metals does the bodyguard allow the hydrogen to escape freely as gas.
Mn(s)+2HNO3тАЛ(aq)тЖТMn(NO3тАЛ)2тАЛ(aq)+H2тАЛ(g) тАФ Chemical equation for reaction of Manganese with very dilute nitric acid.
3M+8HNO3тАЛтЖТ3M(NO3тАЛ)2тАЛ+4H2тАЛO+2NO тАФ General reaction for most metals with dilute nitric acid (where Hydrogen is oxidized).
Nitric acid (HNO3тАЛ) is a powerful oxidizing agent. When it reacts with most metals, it acts as an acid and an oxidizer, converting the liberated H2тАЛ gas into water (H2тАЛO) and reducing itself to nitrogen oxides (NOxтАЛ). However, with very dilute nitric acid and specifically with metals like Manganese (Mn) or Magnesium (Mg), the oxidizing power is weak enough to allow the evolution of hydrogen gas: Mn(s)+2HNO3тАЛ(aq)тЖТMn(NO3тАЛ)2тАЛ(aq)+H2тАЛ(g).
Nitric acid is a strong oxidizing agent.
Very dilute nitric acid (approx1%) allows hydrogen evolution only with specific metals like Mn and Mg.
Most metals produce oxides of nitrogen (NO,N2тАЛO,NO2тАЛ) instead of H2тАЛ when reacting with nitric acid.
The reaction depends on the concentration of the acid and the reactivity of the metal.
Used in identifying metal reactivity behavior in laboratory chemistry.
Studying the oxidation states of nitrogen in redox reactions.
Magnesium (Mg) and Manganese (Mn) are the standard examples in textbooks for this exception.
Option A (Zn), C (Fe), and D (Al) generally follow the standard oxidizing behavior of HNO3тАЛ to release nitrogen oxides rather than hydrogen gas under normal dilution conditions.
B is correct тАФ Manganese (Mn) is the metal that reacts with very dilute nitric acid to evolve hydrogen gas.
Remember the exception: While most metals produce NOx with HNO3тАЛ, only Mg and Mn are exceptions that yield H2тАЛ when the acid is extremely dilute.