Join 60,000+ competitive exam aspirants
Which of the following statements is correct when an acid is dissolved in water? a) The separation of H+ ions from HCl molecules cannot occur in the absence of water. b) Hydrogen ions must always be shown as H+(aq) or hydronium ion (H3тАЛO+).
Only a
Neither a nor b
Both a and b
Only b
Both a and b
When an acid is dissolved in water, the acid molecules ionize to produce hydrogen ions (H+). These ions cannot exist independently in water and immediately react with water molecules to form hydronium ions (H3тАЛO+), which is why both statements (a) and (b) are scientifically correct.
When an acid is dissolved in water, the acid molecules ionize to produce hydrogen ions (H+). These ions cannot exist independently in water and immediately react with water molecules to form hydronium ions (H3тАЛO+), which is why both statements (a) and (b) are scientifically correct.
Think of a free proton as a 'homeless' child; it cannot survive on the street by itself, so it immediately 'adopts' a water molecule to become a stable hydronium ion.
A-Q (Acid + Water = Aqueous/hydronium)
HCl+H2тАЛOтЖТH3тАЛO++ClтИТ тАФ Ionization of hydrochloric acid in water
H++H2тАЛOтЖТH3тАЛO+ тАФ Formation of the hydronium ion
Acids are substances that act as proton donors. In the absence of water, an acid like HCl remains in a covalent molecular state. Upon adding water, the polar water molecules break the HтИТCl bond, releasing H+ ions which then form a coordinate covalent bond with water to become H3тАЛO+. The reaction is represented as: HCl+H2тАЛOтЖТH3тАЛO++ClтИТ
Acidic behavior is only shown in the presence of water.
Hydrogen ions are highly reactive and are always hydrated in an aqueous solution.
Dry litmus paper does not change color in contact with dry HCl gas because no ions are formed.
Explains why acids require moisture to show chemical properties like conductivity or pH changes.
Laboratory testing of acidity using aqueous indicators.
Understanding industrial processes like the production of chlor-alkali.
The term 'hydrogen ion' (H+) is often used interchangeably with 'hydronium ion' (H3тАЛO+) in chemistry, though the latter is more accurate.
Option a is correct because without water, the HтИТCl bond does not break into ions.
Option b is correct because H+ ions are unstable and exist as solvated H3тАЛO+ ions in water.
C is correct тАФ Both statements a and b correctly describe the behavior of an acid when dissolved in water.
Always remember that 'dry' acids do not conduct electricity or turn blue litmus red; moisture is the key to ionic activity!