Join 60,000+ competitive exam aspirants
The approximate cost ration of 220 kV underground cable transmission and 220 kV over head transmission
50
25
13
5
13
The cost ratio between underground (UG) cables and overhead (OH) lines at high voltage levels (like 220 kV) is approximately 13:1. This significant difference arises because UG cables require expensive insulation, complex sheath materials, and extensive civil engineering works for installation compared to the bare conductors used in OH transmission.
The cost ratio between underground (UG) cables and overhead (OH) lines at high voltage levels (like 220 kV) is approximately 13:1. This significant difference arises because UG cables require expensive insulation, complex sheath materials, and extensive civil engineering works for installation compared to the bare conductors used in OH transmission.
Ratio=CostOHтАЛCostUGтАЛтАЛтЙИ13
The higher cost of underground transmission is primarily due to the dielectric material required to withstand high electrical stress, the necessity of moisture-resistant sheaths, and the cost of deep trenching/tunnels. Overhead transmission uses air as the primary insulation, which is free, and requires significantly less civil work, relying instead on structural towers and cross-arms.
Underground cables provide better aesthetics and safety in urban areas but carry significantly higher capital expenditure (CAPEX).
Overhead lines offer better heat dissipation, easier fault location, and lower maintenance costs compared to underground cables.
The cost ratio increases further at higher voltage levels due to the technical complexity of insulation and cable manufacturing.
Underground: Immunity to weather/lightning, no RFI interference, increased public safety.
Overhead: Lower installation cost, easier identification/repair of faults, higher current carrying capacity.
Underground: High dielectric losses, charging current issues, difficult heat dissipation, complex repair.
Overhead: Susceptibility to storms/lightning, visual impact, potential for conductor oscillation.
Underground: Densely populated urban centers, airport vicinity, historical sites.
Overhead: Rural areas, long-distance inter-state bulk power transmission.
| Feature | Underground | Overhead |
|---|---|---|
Insulation | Solid Dielectric | Air |
Installation | Expensive/Complex | Simple/Structural |
For lower voltages (e.g., 11 kV), the ratio is often smaller, but it increases dramatically as voltage increases to 220 kV and beyond.
Other options provided (5, 25, 50) do not reflect the standard engineering estimation for 220 kV systems.
C is correct тАФ The approximate cost ratio of 220 kV underground transmission compared to overhead transmission is 13:1.
Always remember that while underground cabling is preferred for urban aesthetics, the capacitive charging current (IcтАЛ=j╧ЙCV) becomes a major design limitation for long underground cable segments compared to overhead lines.