Join 60,000+ competitive exam aspirants
The main disadvantage(s) of the ward-Leonard system is/are
high initial cost
high maintenance cost
poor overall efficiency
all of the above
all of the above
The Ward-Leonard system is a method of DC motor speed control using a motor-generator (M-G) set to provide variable voltage to the armature of the main motor. It is considered disadvantageous for many modern applications due to the requirement of multiple machines, leading to high capital expenditure, excessive maintenance requirements, and poor overall conversion efficiency.
The Ward-Leonard system is a method of DC motor speed control using a motor-generator (M-G) set to provide variable voltage to the armature of the main motor. It is considered disadvantageous for many modern applications due to the requirement of multiple machines, leading to high capital expenditure, excessive maintenance requirements, and poor overall conversion efficiency.
VaтАЛ=EgтАЛтИТIaтАЛRaтАЛ тАФ Armature voltage equation where EgтАЛ is generator induced EMF.
╬╖totalтАЛ=╬╖IMтАЛ├Ч╬╖GтАЛ├Ч╬╖MтАЛ тАФ Overall system efficiency product of individual machine efficiencies.
The system utilizes an induction motor driving a DC generator whose output voltage is controlled by varying its field current. This variable voltage is applied to the armature of the main DC motor, allowing precise, wide-range speed control in both directions. However, the use of two additional machines (an AC motor and a DC generator) introduces significant mechanical and electrical losses, drastically reducing the system's overall efficiency compared to modern solid-state drives.
The system requires three machines (Induction motor, DC Generator, DC motor) for a single drive.
Speed control is achieved by varying the generator field current.
The system is physically bulky and occupies significant floor space.
Solid-state controlled rectifiers (Thyristors/IGBTs) have largely replaced the Ward-Leonard system.
Smooth and precise speed control over a very wide range.
Excellent inherent braking capabilities (regenerative braking).
Constant torque characteristics are easily maintained.
High initial investment due to three-machine requirement.
High maintenance cost due to rotating parts and commutators.
Poor efficiency due to multiple energy conversion stages.
High floor space occupancy and noise level.
Steel rolling mills
Mine hoists
Electric excavators
Large printing presses
The conversion efficiency is poor because the power passes through three stages of energy conversion (Electrical to Mechanical to Electrical to Mechanical).
Option A, B, and C are all valid technical drawbacks, making D the correct choice.
D is correct тАФ The Ward-Leonard system suffers from high capital expenditure, significant maintenance needs for its three rotating machines, and low overall energy efficiency.
In competitive exams, remember that any system relying on multiple rotating stages for control is almost always inferior in efficiency compared to modern power electronic drives like the Chopper or VFD.