Join 60,000+ competitive exam aspirants
Which of the following distribution system is most economical?
DC system
Single phase AC system
Three phase 3-wire AC system
Three phase 4-wire AC system
DC system
The DC distribution system is considered the most economical because it requires fewer conductors for the same amount of power transmission and involves no dielectric losses or skin effect. Compared to AC systems, DC systems have no reactive power components, resulting in a higher transmission efficiency for a given insulation level.
The DC distribution system is considered the most economical because it requires fewer conductors for the same amount of power transmission and involves no dielectric losses or skin effect. Compared to AC systems, DC systems have no reactive power components, resulting in a higher transmission efficiency for a given insulation level.
VolumeтИЭV21тАЛ тАФ Relationship between conductor volume and operating voltage
P=VI тАФ Basic power relationship in DC systems with no reactive component
In DC systems, the conductor material required is directly proportional to the square of the operating voltage. Because DC does not suffer from inductive reactance or capacitive susceptance, the entire cross-section of the conductor is utilized uniformly (no skin effect), allowing for reduced conductor mass and insulation requirements for a fixed voltage relative to earth.
DC systems eliminate skin effect, ensuring uniform current distribution across the conductor cross-section.
There is no charging current due to capacitance in DC cables, reducing overall losses.
The absence of reactive power leads to a higher power factor (unity) compared to AC.
DC transmission is limited by the difficulty of stepping up voltage for long-distance transport using transformers.
Lower conductor material requirement
No inductive or capacitive reactance losses
No skin effect
Reduced insulation requirement
Difficult to step up or step down DC voltage
Higher maintenance for high-voltage DC switchgear
Corrosion of metallic parts in underground cables
High Voltage Direct Current (HVDC) transmission lines
Industrial electrolysis processes
Electric traction and subway power supply
While DC is mathematically most economical for conductor mass, AC systems are globally preferred due to the ease of voltage transformation via transformers.
Option C and D are AC systems which suffer from impedance losses (Z=R+jX) and skin effects, making them heavier in conductor usage for identical power transfer.
A is correct тАФ The DC distribution system requires the minimum conductor material for a given power and voltage level due to the absence of skin effect and reactive power losses.
Always remember: DC is superior in material usage, but AC is superior in system flexibility due to the Transformer.