Join 60,000+ competitive exam aspirants
Which of the following is not a fire tube boiler ?
Babcock and Wilcox
Lancashire
Locomotive
Cochron
Babcock and Wilcox
The Babcock and Wilcox boiler is a water-tube boiler, whereas the Lancashire, Locomotive, and Cochran boilers are classified as fire-tube boilers. In fire-tube boilers, the products of combustion pass through tubes submerged in water, while in water-tube boilers, water flows inside tubes surrounded by hot flue gases.
The Babcock and Wilcox boiler is a water-tube boiler, whereas the Lancashire, Locomotive, and Cochran boilers are classified as fire-tube boilers. In fire-tube boilers, the products of combustion pass through tubes submerged in water, while in water-tube boilers, water flows inside tubes surrounded by hot flue gases.
P=AFтАЛ тАФ Relation defining pressure capacity based on structural volume
In a Babcock and Wilcox boiler, water circulates through inclined tubes. Hot gases from the furnace pass over the external surface of these tubes multiple times, heating the water and converting it into steam. This arrangement allows for high-pressure operation and greater safety compared to fire-tube designs, which contain a large volume of water in a single shell.
Fire-tube boilers: Flue gases inside tubes, water in shell.
Water-tube boilers: Water inside tubes, flue gases outside.
Babcock and Wilcox is the most common stationary water-tube boiler.
Water-tube boilers are suitable for high pressure (>20 bar) and large scale power generation.
Water-tube boilers have higher steam generation rates.
Less danger of explosion due to smaller water capacity.
Easier to transport and install due to modular design.
Water-tube boilers require highly treated feed water to prevent scale.
Maintenance of water-tube boilers is more complex than simple fire-tube designs.
Power plants for high-pressure steam generation.
Marine propulsion systems.
Large industrial processing plants.
| Feature | Water-Tube | Fire-Tube |
|---|---|---|
Medium in Tubes | Water | Flue Gases |
Pressure Range | High (> 20 bar) | Low (< 20 bar) |
The Cochran boiler is a vertical, multi-tubular fire-tube boiler.
Lancashire boiler is a stationary, horizontal, fire-tube boiler with large shell diameter.
Locomotive boiler is a mobile, horizontal, fire-tube, multi-tubular boiler.
A is correct тАФ Babcock and Wilcox is a water-tube boiler, not a fire-tube boiler.
Always remember that 'water-tube' implies 'water inside' and 'fire-tube' implies 'fire/flue-gas inside'; high-pressure thermal plants exclusively use water-tube designs.