Join 60,000+ competitive exam aspirants
Which of the following boilers cannot be employed for generating steam at 100 atmosphere ?
Cochron boiler
Lancashire boiler
Locomotive boiler
All of above
All of above
Cochran, Lancashire, and Locomotive boilers are classified as 'low to medium pressure' fire-tube boilers. These designs are structurally limited by the difficulty of maintaining a pressure-tight cylindrical shell at high pressures, typically operating well below 20 bar, whereas high-pressure requirements (100 atm) necessitate water-tube boiler designs.
Cochran, Lancashire, and Locomotive boilers are classified as 'low to medium pressure' fire-tube boilers. These designs are structurally limited by the difficulty of maintaining a pressure-tight cylindrical shell at high pressures, typically operating well below 20 bar, whereas high-pressure requirements (100 atm) necessitate water-tube boiler designs.
╧ГhтАЛ=2tPDтАЛ тАФ Hoop stress formula for cylindrical pressure vessels
PmaxтАЛтЙИ20┬аbar тАФ Practical upper limit for fire-tube boilers
In fire-tube boilers, combustion gases flow through tubes submerged in water, surrounded by a large cylindrical shell. As pressure increases, the shell wall thickness required to withstand hoop stress (sigmahтАЛ=2tPDтАЛ) becomes prohibitively large, making the vessel heavy, prone to overheating at joints, and susceptible to explosive failure at 100 atm (approx. 10 MPa). Conversely, high-pressure boilers use small-diameter water tubes that handle high internal pressure with much thinner walls.
Fire-tube boilers have the water in the shell and hot gases in the tubes.
Water-tube boilers are essential for high-pressure applications (e.g., Benson, La-Mont, or Loeffler boilers).
Increasing pressure significantly increases the stress on the large diameter shell of fire-tube boilers.
100 atmosphere is approximately 101.3 bar, far exceeding the capacity of standard fire-tube designs.
Simple construction for fire-tube boilers
High-pressure water-tube boilers offer rapid steam generation
Low pressure capacity of fire-tube boilers
Risk of catastrophic shell explosion at high pressures
Small industrial steam requirements (Lancashire)
Locomotive steam generation (Locomotive boiler)
Small to medium process heat (Cochran)
Cochran boiler is a vertical fire-tube boiler.
Lancashire boiler is a stationary horizontal fire-tube boiler.
Locomotive boiler is a mobile horizontal fire-tube boiler.
All these are inherently unsuitable for supercritical or high-pressure power plant cycles.
D is correct тАФ All listed boilers are fire-tube designs that cannot safely withstand a pressure as high as 100 atmospheres.
Always remember that fire-tube boilers (like Cochran, Lancashire, Locomotive) are for low-pressure, while water-tube boilers (Babcock & Wilcox, Benson) are for high-pressure power generation.