Join 60,000+ competitive exam aspirants
In the following question, two statements are followed by four conclusions. You have to assume the given statements to be true, even if they seem to be at variance with commonly known facts. Read the conclusions carefully and then decide which of the given conclusions logically follows from the statements.
Statements:
Some books are pens.
All pens are pencils.
Conclusions:
I. Some books are pencils
II. All books are pencils
III. No book is pencil
IV. Some pens are books
Only I
Only II
Both I and IV
Only IV
Both I and IV
In syllogisms, use the conversion rule: 'Some A are B' always implies 'Some B are A', and the transitive property: if 'Some A are B' and 'All B are C', then 'Some A are C'.
In syllogisms, use the conversion rule: 'Some A are B' always implies 'Some B are A', and the transitive property: if 'Some A are B' and 'All B are C', then 'Some A are C'.
Analyze Statements
Statement 1: Some books are pens (means there is an intersection between set Book and set Pen). Statement 2: All pens are pencils (means the set Pen is completely inside the set Pencil).
Evaluate Conclusions
Conclusion I: Some books are pencils follows because the intersection of books and pens is part of the pencil set. Conclusion IV: Some pens are books follows from the direct conversion of 'Some books are pens'.
Evaluate Exclusions
Conclusion II is false because we only know some books are pencils, not all. Conclusion III is false as it directly contradicts the presence of the intersection found in step 1.
A: Incorrect because it ignores the validity of conclusion IV. B: Incorrect as 'All books are pencils' is not supported by the premises. D: Incorrect because it ignores the validity of conclusion I.
C is correct because both conclusion I (Some books are pencils) and conclusion IV (Some pens are books) are logically derived from the given premises.
For syllogisms involving 'Some' and 'All', draw the overlapping circles immediately; the 'Some' relationship is always reversible, but 'All' is only reversible if both sets are identical.