Join 60,000+ competitive exam aspirants
In the following question, two statements are followed by two conclusions. You have to assume the given statements to be true, even if they seem to be at variance with commonly known facts. Read both the conclusions and then decide which of the given conclusions logically follows from the statements.
Statements:
No glass is plastic.
All plastic is synthetic.
Conclusions:
I. No glass is synthetic.
II. All synthetics are plastic.
Only conclusion I follows
Only conclusion II follows
Both conclusions I and II follow
Neither conclusion I nor II follows
Neither conclusion I nor II follows
Use Venn diagram visualization: The glass and plastic circles are separate, but the synthetic circle encompasses all plastic and may overlap with part of the glass circle.
Use Venn diagram visualization: The glass and plastic circles are separate, but the synthetic circle encompasses all plastic and may overlap with part of the glass circle.
Analyze Statement 1
No glass is plastic. This creates two disjoint sets: Glass (G) and Plastic (P), meaning no overlap between G and P.
Analyze Statement 2
All plastic is synthetic. This means the Plastic set is a subset of the Synthetic (S) set. Therefore, P is inside S.
Evaluate Conclusions
Conclusion I: No glass is synthetic is false because while plastic cannot be glass, the synthetic set can overlap with glass. Conclusion II: All synthetics are plastic is false because some synthetics are definitely plastic, but not necessarily all.
A: Incorrect because the relationship between synthetic and glass is indeterminate, not definitely negative. B: Incorrect because 'All synthetics are plastic' is a conversion error; only the reverse is true. C: Incorrect because both conclusions are invalid based on the provided statements.
D is correct because neither conclusion is logically necessitated by the statements; there is no definitive link between glass and synthetic, and the converse of 'All P is S' does not follow.
In syllogisms, avoid assuming a relationship exists just because two terms appear in different statements; always look for an explicit connection or shared middle term.