Join 60,000+ competitive exam aspirants
In the following question, two statements are followed by two conclusions. You have to assume the given statements to be true, even if they seem to be at variance with commonly known facts. Read both the conclusions and then decide which of the given conclusions logically follows from the statements.
Statements:
Some flowers are yellow.
All yellow things are bright.
Conclusions:
I. Some flowers are bright.
II. All flowers are bright.
Only conclusion I follows
Only conclusion II follows
Both conclusions I and II follow
Neither conclusion I nor II follows
Only conclusion I follows
Visualize Venn diagrams: Since yellow is contained within bright, any overlap with yellow automatically extends into the bright region.
Visualize Venn diagrams: Since yellow is contained within bright, any overlap with yellow automatically extends into the bright region.
Visualize Statement Relations
Draw a circle for 'Yellow'. Since 'All yellow are bright', the 'Yellow' circle is completely inside the 'Bright' circle. Draw a circle for 'Flowers' that overlaps with 'Yellow'.
Analyze Conclusion I
Because 'Flowers' overlaps with 'Yellow' and 'Yellow' is entirely within 'Bright', the overlapping part of 'Flowers' must also lie within 'Bright'. Thus, some flowers are definitely bright.
Analyze Conclusion II
The statements only guarantee that the portion of flowers that are yellow are also bright. There is no information suggesting all flowers must be yellow or bright; hence, 'All flowers are bright' is not necessarily true.
B: Incorrect because 'All flowers are bright' is not supported by the premise that only 'some' flowers are yellow. C: Incorrect because it wrongly assumes conclusion II is valid. D: Incorrect because conclusion I is logically sound based on the intersection.
A is correct because the intersection of flowers and yellow ensures that the specific subset of flowers that are yellow must also be bright, while the extent of non-yellow flowers remains unknown.
In Syllogism questions with 'Some', always verify if the conclusion is a necessary truth. If it is only a possibility, it is considered false in these exams.