Join 60,000+ competitive exam aspirants
Mechanical efficiency of a gas turbine in comparison to that of reciprocating IC engine is
Lower
Higher
Same
Unpredictable
Higher
The mechanical efficiency of a gas turbine is higher than that of a reciprocating IC engine primarily because it utilizes rotary motion rather than reciprocating motion. This design eliminates complex mechanisms like crankshafts, connecting rods, and piston-cylinder friction losses associated with reciprocating parts.
The mechanical efficiency of a gas turbine is higher than that of a reciprocating IC engine primarily because it utilizes rotary motion rather than reciprocating motion. This design eliminates complex mechanisms like crankshafts, connecting rods, and piston-cylinder friction losses associated with reciprocating parts.
╬╖mechтАЛ=IndicatedPowerBrakePowerтАЛ тАФ Definition of mechanical efficiency
PlossтАЛ=PfricтАЛ+PauxтАЛ тАФ Total mechanical losses
In a reciprocating engine, a large portion of the generated work is consumed by friction in the piston-cylinder interface, valves, and the conversion of reciprocating motion into rotary motion through the crankshaft. Conversely, a gas turbine is a steady-flow device with fewer moving parts, all exhibiting continuous rotary motion, which leads to significantly lower mechanical losses and higher overall mechanical efficiency.
Reciprocating engines suffer from high friction due to the piston rings and cylinder wall interaction.
Gas turbines maintain steady-flow conditions, reducing wear and mechanical drag.
Mechanical efficiency in turbines is typically above 95%, whereas IC engines usually range from 80-90%.
Higher power-to-weight ratio
Lower mechanical losses due to absence of reciprocating components
Requires high-grade materials to withstand thermal stress
Lower thermal efficiency at part-load compared to IC engines
Aircraft propulsion
Large-scale power generation
| Feature | IC Engine | Gas Turbine |
|---|---|---|
Motion Type | Reciprocating | Rotary |
Mechanical Losses | High | Low |
Mechanical efficiency is defined as the ratio of output power available at the shaft (Brake Power) to the power developed inside the engine (Indicated Power).
Option A is incorrect because friction losses in the crank-connecting rod mechanism significantly reduce mechanical efficiency in IC engines compared to turbines.
B is correct тАФ Gas turbines exhibit higher mechanical efficiency due to the absence of reciprocating masses and sliding friction inherent in IC engine pistons.
Always remember that 'Mechanical Efficiency' strictly refers to losses between Indicated Power and Brake Power; it is independent of thermodynamic or thermal efficiency.