Join 60,000+ competitive exam aspirants
Overall efficiency of gas turbine is
Less than that of diesel cycle
More than that of diesel cycle
More than that of otto cycle
Equal to that of rankine or carnot cycle
Less than that of diesel cycle
The overall efficiency of a gas turbine cycle (Brayton cycle) is generally lower than that of the Diesel cycle for equivalent compression ratios and operating conditions. The Diesel cycle benefits from higher maximum cycle temperatures and constant-pressure combustion combined with constant-volume heat rejection, typically resulting in higher thermal efficiency.
The overall efficiency of a gas turbine cycle (Brayton cycle) is generally lower than that of the Diesel cycle for equivalent compression ratios and operating conditions. The Diesel cycle benefits from higher maximum cycle temperatures and constant-pressure combustion combined with constant-volume heat rejection, typically resulting in higher thermal efficiency.
╬╖BraytonтАЛ=1тИТrp╬│╬│тИТ1тАЛтАЛ1тАЛ тАФ Efficiency of Ideal Brayton Cycle
╬╖DieselтАЛ=1тИТr╬│тИТ11тАЛ[╬│(╧БтИТ1)╧Б╬│тИТ1тАЛ] тАФ Efficiency of Ideal Diesel Cycle
Gas turbines operate on the Brayton cycle, involving isentropic compression, constant-pressure heat addition, isentropic expansion, and constant-pressure heat rejection. Because gas turbines have high parasitic work (the compressor consumes a significant portion of the turbine's output work) and limitations on maximum turbine inlet temperatures due to metallurgical constraints, the overall conversion efficiency is lower compared to high-compression ratio reciprocating engines like Diesel engines.
The Brayton cycle efficiency is highly dependent on the pressure ratio (rpтАЛ).
Gas turbines are limited by the turbine inlet temperature (TmaxтАЛ) to protect turbine blades.
Diesel cycles achieve higher thermal efficiency by operating at much higher peak pressures.
Reciprocating engines (Diesel) exhibit lower heat transfer losses compared to the continuous flow process of gas turbines.
High power-to-weight ratio
Continuous power delivery
Ability to burn various fuels
Lower thermal efficiency compared to large-scale diesel or combined cycles
Expensive materials required for high-temperature turbine blades
High sensitivity to ambient air temperature
Aircraft propulsion
Peak load power generation
Industrial gas compressors
| Feature | Gas Turbine | Diesel Engine |
|---|---|---|
Efficiency | Moderate (~30-40%) | High (~40-50%) |
The overall efficiency of an open-cycle gas turbine is typically 30-35%, whereas modern diesel engines can exceed 45-50%.
Option D is incorrect because the Carnot cycle defines the theoretical maximum efficiency (╬╖=1тИТTHтАЛTLтАЛтАЛ), which is always greater than any real-world gas turbine cycle.
A is correct тАФ The thermal efficiency of the Brayton cycle is generally lower than that of the Diesel cycle due to inherent limitations in pressure ratio and the significant work required for compression.
Remember that efficiency comparisons in exams often assume ideal conditions, but the fundamental reason remains the impact of the compression ratio and heat rejection process types.