Join 60,000+ competitive exam aspirants
In this question, a statement is followed by two courses of action, numbered I and II. You must assume everything in the statement to be true and on the basis of the information given in the statement, decide which of the courses of action logically follow(s) for pursuing.
Statement: The special task force set up by the government has found that toxic waste is being mixed with dry waste by many apartment complexes before collection by the municipality, causing severe danger to the waste processing personnel and the environment.
Courses of Action:
I. Apartment complexes should be heavily penalised in instances where toxic and dry waste is not properly segregated before collection. II. Apartment complexes should issue clear guidelines on waste segregation to the apartment residents.
Neither I nor II follows
Only II follows
Both I and II follow
Only I follows
Both I and II follow
Evaluate whether each course of action is practically viable, directly addresses the problem stated in the statement, and is a sensible administrative step without being overly extreme or impractical.
Evaluate whether each course of action is practically viable, directly addresses the problem stated in the statement, and is a sensible administrative step without being overly extreme or impractical.
Analyze the Statement
A special task force found that apartment complexes mix toxic waste with dry waste, creating severe safety and environmental hazards for waste workers.
Evaluate Course of Action I
Heavy penalization acts as an immediate administrative deterrent to prevent apartment complexes from violating waste disposal norms. Hence, I follows.
Evaluate Course of Action II
Issuing clear guidelines to residents addresses the root cause of ignorance or improper sorting at the individual level within apartments. Hence, II follows.
A: Only II follows is incorrect because both punitive action and resident guidelines are required. B: Neither I nor II follows is incorrect because both courses are practically sound and logical. D: Only I follows is incorrect because educating residents via guidelines is equally essential.
Both I and II follow is correct because penalization enforces legal compliance and strict adherence, while issuing clear guidelines ensures residents are properly educated on segregation practices.
In Course of Action questions, always look for a balanced combination of preventive/educational steps and punitive/regulatory measures.