Join 60,000+ competitive exam aspirants
Given below is a statement followed by two possible reasons numbered I and II. Read the statement carefully and decide which of the two explains the event/observation/information given in the statement. Statement - Even though Town B has a rich history and many ancient landmarks, it is not a popular tourist destination. I. The town has poor public transportation and limited accommodation options. II. Town B is located near a popular beach destination.
Both I and II are possible reasons
Only II is a possible reason
Only I is a possible reason
Neither I nor II is a possible reason
Only I is a possible reason
Identify reasons that directly address the lack of popularity despite the presence of historical landmarks.
Identify reasons that directly address the lack of popularity despite the presence of historical landmarks.
Evaluate Reason I
Reason I states that the town lacks basic tourism infrastructure (transport and accommodation). This is a strong logical cause for why a place with historical significance fails to attract tourists.
Evaluate Reason II
Reason II suggests the town is near a popular beach. Proximity to a successful tourist destination usually increases the flow of visitors, making it a poor explanation for why the town is NOT popular.
A: Incorrect because II is not a valid reason. B: Incorrect because it includes II. D: Incorrect because I is a valid logical reason.
C is correct because poor infrastructure (I) acts as a significant deterrent for tourism, whereas proximity to a popular destination (II) would typically act as a facilitator rather than a cause for lack of popularity.
In critical reasoning 'possible reasons' questions, always check if the reason acts as a barrier or a boost to the outcome described in the statement.