Join 60,000+ competitive exam aspirants
The thermal efficiency of a boiler water reactor is ___ that of a pressurized water reactor.
Greater than
Equal to
Less than
Insufficient data
Greater than
Boiling Water Reactors (BWR) have a higher thermal efficiency compared to Pressurized Water Reactors (PWR) because the steam is generated directly within the reactor vessel and delivered to the turbine at a higher temperature and pressure without the thermal resistance of a steam generator. In a PWR, the primary coolant loop must be kept at higher pressures to prevent boiling, which necessitates a secondary loop, introducing a temperature drop across the steam generator.
Boiling Water Reactors (BWR) have a higher thermal efficiency compared to Pressurized Water Reactors (PWR) because the steam is generated directly within the reactor vessel and delivered to the turbine at a higher temperature and pressure without the thermal resistance of a steam generator. In a PWR, the primary coolant loop must be kept at higher pressures to prevent boiling, which necessitates a secondary loop, introducing a temperature drop across the steam generator.
╬╖thтАЛ=QinтАЛWnetтАЛтАЛ тАФ Fundamental definition of thermal efficiency
╬╖carnotтАЛ=1тИТThotтАЛTcoldтАЛтАЛ тАФ Theoretical limit based on temperatures
In a BWR, the reactor core boils water directly into steam, which is separated and sent to the turbine, resulting in a single-loop cycle. In contrast, a PWR uses a two-loop system: the primary loop stays liquid under high pressure and transfers heat to the secondary loop via a heat exchanger (steam generator). This secondary loop then produces the steam for the turbine, leading to unavoidable thermal losses and lower net efficiency due to the second law of thermodynamics limiting the cycle's temperature difference.
BWR operates on a direct cycle, reducing components that cause heat loss.
PWR requires a secondary loop to generate steam, adding thermal impedance.
BWR typically achieves 1-2% higher net thermal efficiency than PWR.
Higher steam temperature at the turbine inlet correlates to higher Rankine cycle efficiency.
Simpler primary circuit design in BWR
No steam generator required in BWR
Reduced potential for heat transfer losses
Radioactive steam carries over to turbine components in BWR
PWR has a more robust primary containment system
PWR allows for easier fuel handling and core maintenance
Nuclear Power Generation
Marine Propulsion
| Feature | BWR | PWR |
|---|---|---|
Steam Generation | Direct in Vessel | Indirect via Heat Exchanger |
Thermal Efficiency | Higher (~33-34%) | Lower (~30-32%) |
The thermal efficiency is governed by the Carnot efficiency principle where higher temperature differentials yield better results.
Option C is incorrect because it describes the inverse of the actual engineering performance observed in these reactor types.
A is correct тАФ The thermal efficiency of a BWR is greater than that of a PWR because it eliminates the heat exchanger temperature drop found in the PWR's secondary loop.
In power systems, always analyze whether the cycle is a 'direct' or 'indirect' thermal process, as indirect processes almost always incur an efficiency penalty due to heat exchanger temperature gradients.