Join 60,000+ competitive exam aspirants
Which of the following statement is not true w.r.t. 3-Point and 4-Point DC shunt motor starter?
Both can limit high starting current
both can provide overload protection
both can provide No voltage protection
both can be used where speed control is required using the field control method.
both can be used where speed control is required using the field control method.
The 3-point starter connects the No-Volt Release (NVR) coil in series with the shunt field circuit. If the field current is weakened for speed control, the NVR may de-energize, causing the starter handle to return to the OFF position, which makes the 3-point starter unsuitable for wide speed control. The 4-point starter overcomes this by connecting the NVR coil independently across the supply lines, allowing field current variations without affecting the NVR functionality.
The 3-point starter connects the No-Volt Release (NVR) coil in series with the shunt field circuit. If the field current is weakened for speed control, the NVR may de-energize, causing the starter handle to return to the OFF position, which makes the 3-point starter unsuitable for wide speed control. The 4-point starter overcomes this by connecting the NVR coil independently across the supply lines, allowing field current variations without affecting the NVR functionality.
NтИЭ╬жEbтАЛтАЛ тАФ Relation between speed, back emf, and flux
╬жтИЭIshтАЛ тАФ Relation between flux and shunt field current
The 3-point starter uses the field current (IshтАЛ) to energize the NVR electromagnet. When a field regulator is used to increase speed, the field current decreases, which can drop below the threshold required to hold the handle, causing nuisance tripping. The 4-point starter uses a separate parallel path for the NVR, keeping its current constant regardless of the field regulator adjustment.
3-point starter has three terminals: L (Line), A (Armature), and F (Field).
4-point starter has four terminals: L1, L2, A, and F, where L2 is connected to the NVR coil.
No-Voltage Release (NVR) is essential for safety to prevent auto-restart after power loss.
Field control method involves increasing RshтАЛ which reduces ╬ж and increases speed N.
4-point starter allows wide range of speed control.
3-point starter is simpler and cheaper for fixed-speed motors.
3-point starter suffers from nuisance tripping during high-speed operation.
4-point starter does not protect against open-field failure if the regulator is faulty.
3-point starter: Constant speed DC shunt motors.
4-point starter: Variable speed DC shunt motors requiring field weakening control.
| Feature | 3-Point Starter | 4-Point Starter |
|---|---|---|
NVR Coil Connection | Series with Field | Parallel with Supply |
Speed Control | Limited range | Wide range |
The 4-point starter provides overload and no-voltage protection but lacks inherent protection against field failure.
Option D is false because the 3-point starter cannot be reliably used for field-weakening speed control due to its dependency on field current for the NVR magnet strength.
D is correct тАФ The 3-point starter is unsuitable for field-control speed regulation as it causes the NVR coil to release the handle when field current is reduced.
Always remember that in the 4-point starter, the NVR coil circuit is independent of the field circuit, making it the preferred choice for wide-range speed control.