Join 60,000+ competitive exam aspirants
Select the option that is appropriate regarding the following two statements labelled Assertion and Reason. Assertion: In urban areas, roofing on built-up areas, concrete and asphalts surfaces are major factors that inhibit infiltration and surface retention. Reason: The presence of pervious surface areas decreases infiltration and initial losses and leads to consequent increase in the effective rainfall.
Assertion is true, but Reason is false.
Both Assertion and Reason are true and Reason is the correct explanation of Assertion.
Both Assertion and Reason are false.
Both Assertion and Reason are true, but Reason is not the correct explanation of Assertion.
Assertion is true, but Reason is false.
Urbanization reduces surface permeability through the use of impervious materials like concrete and asphalt, which significantly inhibit infiltration and natural recharge. The reason provided is incorrect because pervious surfaces increase infiltration and decrease surface runoff, whereas the statement claims they increase effective rainfall.
IS 10500:2012 (Groundwater hydrology principles)
Urbanization reduces surface permeability through the use of impervious materials like concrete and asphalt, which significantly inhibit infiltration and natural recharge. The reason provided is incorrect because pervious surfaces increase infiltration and decrease surface runoff, whereas the statement claims they increase effective rainfall.
ftтАЛ=fcтАЛ+(f0тАЛтИТfcтАЛ)eтИТkt тАФ Horton's Infiltration Equation representing the rate of infiltration ftтАЛ at time t.
R=PтИТIтИТ╬жt тАФ Simplified runoff model where R is runoff, P is precipitation, and I is initial loss.
Infiltration capacity f is a measure of the soil's ability to absorb water. Impervious surfaces cover the natural soil profile, effectively setting the infiltration capacity f=0 for those areas. This forces a higher volume of rainfall to remain on the surface as direct runoff, which is governed by the water balance equation P=R+I+E, where P is precipitation, R is runoff, I is infiltration, and E is evaporation.
Impervious surfaces act as catalysts for flash floods in urban catchments.
Pervious surfaces allow water to percolate into the subsurface, thereby reducing the peak discharge of runoff.
Effective rainfall is the portion of rainfall that contributes directly to surface runoff.
Groundwater recharge is enhanced by pervious surfaces.
Reduced storm drainage requirements for permeable urban designs.
Urban sprawl limits natural drainage paths.
Compaction of soil during construction reduces inherent porosity.
Urban watershed management
Stormwater drainage network design
Groundwater basin modeling
The reason statement contradicts the principle of hydrology; pervious surfaces (like soil or grass) facilitate infiltration, thereby reducing runoff, not increasing it.
Option A is correct because the assertion accurately describes the effect of urbanization, while the reason misrepresents the hydrological role of pervious surfaces.
A is correct тАФ The assertion correctly highlights that urbanization restricts infiltration, while the reason is logically flawed as pervious surfaces enhance infiltration rather than increasing effective runoff.
In exams, always analyze the causal link in 'Reason'. If the mechanism described is the exact opposite of standard physical principles (e.g., pervious = high infiltration), the reason is likely false.