Join 60,000+ competitive exam aspirants
Which of the fallowing types of construction offers comparatively better earthquake resistance based on its structural action? Consider that the thickness and length of member to be constructed is constant for any of the following cases.
Reinforced brickwork
Brickwork with English bond
Random rubble stone masonry
Size stone masonry
Reinforced brickwork
Reinforced brickwork provides significantly better earthquake resistance compared to unreinforced masonry because the addition of steel reinforcement allows the masonry to handle tensile stresses that occur during lateral seismic loading. Unreinforced masonry structures exhibit poor ductility and tend to fail in a brittle manner under shear forces induced by seismic vibrations.
IS 4326:2013 (Code of practice for earthquake resistant design and construction of buildings)
Reinforced brickwork provides significantly better earthquake resistance compared to unreinforced masonry because the addition of steel reinforcement allows the masonry to handle tensile stresses that occur during lateral seismic loading. Unreinforced masonry structures exhibit poor ductility and tend to fail in a brittle manner under shear forces induced by seismic vibrations.
VbтАЛ=AhтАЛ├ЧW тАФ where VbтАЛ is design base shear, AhтАЛ is design horizontal seismic coefficient, and W is seismic weight.
╧Д=bdVтАЛ тАФ where ╧Д represents shear stress in the masonry cross-section.
During an earthquake, lateral forces cause bending and shear in walls. Plain brickwork has almost zero tensile strength, leading to crack propagation. By embedding steel bars, the reinforcement acts as a tie that absorbs the tensile stresses generated by the horizontal base shear (VbтАЛ=AhтАЛ├ЧW), effectively providing a composite material that can resist deformation and energy dissipation through a controlled ductile response.
Unreinforced masonry is essentially brittle with negligible tensile strength.
Reinforced masonry transforms a brittle material into a pseudo-ductile system.
Steel reinforcement provides continuity, preventing walls from collapsing outward during cyclic ground motion.
Bond strength between mortar and reinforcement is critical for the composite action.
Improved energy dissipation capacity
Enhanced tensile and flexural strength
Prevents catastrophic brittle failure
Higher material cost due to steel reinforcement
Requires skilled labor for precise placement of bars
Potential for corrosion if concrete/mortar cover is insufficient
Load-bearing walls in seismic zones
Confined masonry construction
Strengthening of existing masonry heritage structures
IS 4326 provides detailed guidelines for seismic reinforcement in masonry buildings.
English bond (Option B) is a method for aesthetic/structural bonding of bricks but offers no inherent resistance to seismic tensile loads.
Random rubble and Size stone masonry (Options C and D) are inherently unstable under seismic forces due to the lack of monolithic action and high self-weight compared to brickwork.
A is correct тАФ Reinforced brickwork is the only option that utilizes embedded reinforcement to withstand seismic tensile and shear forces.
Always remember that in earthquake engineering, the primary failure mode of masonry is brittle tension; therefore, any technique adding reinforcement is superior to purely mass-based resistance.