Join 60,000+ competitive exam aspirants
A bank has equally qualified male and female managers, but only male managers handle VIP clients. Which inference is valid?
Only males are trained
Possible gender bias in client allocation
Females avoid VIP clients
Female managers are new
Possible gender bias in client allocation
Identify the logical disconnect between two equal entities and an unequal outcome, which points directly to systemic bias or external factors rather than innate ability or individual choice.
Identify the logical disconnect between two equal entities and an unequal outcome, which points directly to systemic bias or external factors rather than innate ability or individual choice.
Analyze the Premises
The statement establishes two facts: 1) Male and female managers are equally qualified. 2) Only male managers handle VIP clients. The core issue is the restricted access for female managers despite their equal qualification.
Evaluate Inference B
Since qualifications are identical, the exclusion of females from VIP client handling suggests that the selection criteria is based on gender rather than merit, which defines gender bias.
A: The premise states they are equally qualified, implying they have received similar training. C: This is an assumption unsupported by the data, as the premise does not mention employee preference. D: Being 'new' is an external assumption not supported by the premise of equal qualification.
B is correct because the equality of qualifications implies that the disparity in role assignment is likely due to subjective gender preferences rather than objective ability.
In inference questions, avoid adding information not explicitly present in the passage; always look for the most neutral conclusion that explains the discrepancy between equal inputs and unequal outputs.