Join 60,000+ competitive exam aspirants
An international firm has 40%% female engineers, but in overseas projects, only 5%% of assigned engineers are women despite equal qualifications and experience levels.
Which inference is valid?
Overseas work needs male skills
Policy favours men for overseas roles
Women decline overseas work
Men adapt better abroad
Policy favours men for overseas roles
Compare the base percentage (40%) with the actual allocation (5%). Since qualifications are equal, a massive gap in allocation points to a systematic selection bias (policy).
Firm has 40% female engineers. Overseas projects have only 5% female engineers. All candidates have equal qualifications and experience.
Discrepancy=AvailabilityтИТSelection┬аRate
Compare the base percentage (40%) with the actual allocation (5%). Since qualifications are equal, a massive gap in allocation points to a systematic selection bias (policy).
Assuming the difference is due to personal choice or capability without considering the provided condition of 'equal qualifications and experience'.
Analyze the Data
The firm employs 40% women. If merit were the sole factor, we would expect a similar percentage in overseas roles, given the statement that qualifications are equal.
ExpectedтЙИ40%,Actual=5%
Evaluate the Gap
The significant drop from 40% to 5% indicates that external factors (other than ability) are influencing the selection process for overseas projects.
40%тИТ5%=35%┬а(Unexplained┬аGap)
Conclude the Inference
Since the question explicitly states that qualifications and experience levels are equal, we must reject theories based on skill or individual preference, leaving organizational policy as the logical cause.
PolicyюАа=Merit
B is correct because the large discrepancy between the general workforce composition (40%) and overseas assignments (5%) for equally qualified individuals implies a selective bias in organizational policy.
In critical reasoning questions, always prioritize the given premises; if the premise specifies equal skill/qualifications, you must exclude all options suggesting differential aptitude or preference.