Join 60,000+ competitive exam aspirants
A sample of soil failed in a triaxial test under a deviator stress of 200 kN/m 2 when the confining pressure was 100 kN/m 2 . For the sample, if the confining pressure had been 200 kN/m 2 , what would have been the deviator stress at failure? Assume c = 0.
500 kN/m┬▓
600 kN/m┬▓
100 kN/m┬▓
400 kN/m┬▓
400 kN/m┬▓
For a cohesionless soil (c=0), the Mohr-Coulomb failure criterion states that the major principal stress at failure ╧Г1тАЛ is related to the confining pressure ╧Г3тАЛ by the ratio ╧Г3тАЛ╧Г1тАЛтАЛ=tan2(45┬░+2╧ХтАЛ). Given the deviator stress ╧ГdтАЛ=╧Г1тАЛтИТ╧Г3тАЛ, a constant ratio of ╧Г1тАЛ/╧Г3тАЛ implies that ╧ГdтАЛ is directly proportional to ╧Г3тАЛ.
IS 2720-11:1993
For a cohesionless soil (c=0), the Mohr-Coulomb failure criterion states that the major principal stress at failure ╧Г1тАЛ is related to the confining pressure ╧Г3тАЛ by the ratio ╧Г3тАЛ╧Г1тАЛтАЛ=tan2(45┬░+2╧ХтАЛ). Given the deviator stress ╧ГdтАЛ=╧Г1тАЛтИТ╧Г3тАЛ, a constant ratio of ╧Г1тАЛ/╧Г3тАЛ implies that ╧ГdтАЛ is directly proportional to ╧Г3тАЛ.
╧Г1тАЛ=╧Г3тАЛtan2(45┬░+2╧ХтАЛ) тАФ Mohr-Coulomb failure criterion for c=0
╧ГdтАЛ=╧Г1тАЛтИТ╧Г3тАЛ=╧Г3тАЛ(tan2(45┬░+2╧ХтАЛ)тИТ1) тАФ Relationship between deviator stress and confining pressure
In a cohesionless soil, the shear strength is purely frictional. As the confining pressure increases, the normal stress on the failure plane increases, allowing the soil to support a higher deviator stress before failure occurs. Since ╧Г1тАЛ=╧Г3тАЛтЛЕN╧ХтАЛ (where N╧ХтАЛ=tan2(45┬░+2╧ХтАЛ)), we have ╧ГdтАЛ=╧Г1тАЛтИТ╧Г3тАЛ=╧Г3тАЛ(N╧ХтАЛтИТ1). Thus, ╧ГdтАЛ scales linearly with ╧Г3тАЛ.
For cohesionless soils (c=0), the ratio ╧Г3тАЛ╧Г1тАЛтАЛ is constant for a given soil.
The deviator stress ╧ГdтАЛ is directly proportional to the confining pressure ╧Г3тАЛ.
Given ╧Гd1тАЛ=200 at ╧Г3(1)тАЛ=100, doubling the confining pressure to ╧Г3(2)тАЛ=200 doubles the deviator stress to 400.
Linear relationship simplifies calculation for sands.
Requires only one test point to determine the strength parameters for cohesionless soil.
Not applicable to cohesive soils where cюАа=0.
Assumes the internal friction angle ╧Х remains constant across pressure ranges.
Foundation design on sandy soils.
Slope stability analysis for granular materials.
The calculation: ╧Гd1тАЛ╧Гd2тАЛтАЛ=╧Г3(1)тАЛ╧Г3(2)тАЛтАЛтЗТ200╧Гd2тАЛтАЛ=100200тАЛтЗТ╧Гd2тАЛ=400┬аkN/m2.
Option A, B, and C are incorrect as they do not follow the linear proportionality derived from the Mohr-Coulomb theory for c=0 soils.
D is correct тАФ For a cohesionless soil (c=0), the deviator stress at failure is directly proportional to the confining pressure, so doubling the pressure results in doubling the deviator stress.
Always check if the soil is cohesive (c>0) or cohesionless (c=0) first; if c=0, use the ratio method, otherwise use the full Mohr-Coulomb equation ╧Г1тАЛ=╧Г3тАЛN╧ХтАЛ+2cN╧ХтАЛтАЛ.