Join 60,000+ competitive exam aspirants
The chances of diagonal tension cracks in R.C.C. member reduce when ________.
only shear force act
flexural and shear force act
axial tension and shear force act simultaneously
axial compression and shear force act simultaneously
axial compression and shear force act simultaneously
Diagonal tension cracks in R.C.C. beams are primarily caused by the principal tensile stress exceeding the tensile strength of concrete. When axial compression is applied, it creates a counteracting compressive stress that reduces the magnitude of the resultant principal tensile stress within the section.
IS 456:2000, Cl. 40
Diagonal tension cracks in R.C.C. beams are primarily caused by the principal tensile stress exceeding the tensile strength of concrete. When axial compression is applied, it creates a counteracting compressive stress that reduces the magnitude of the resultant principal tensile stress within the section.
╧ГtтАЛ=2╧ГxтАЛтАЛ+(2╧ГxтАЛтАЛ)2+╧Дxy2тАЛтАЛ тАФ Principal tensile stress formula where ╧ГxтАЛ is axial stress and ╧ДxyтАЛ is shear stress.
VcтАЛ=╧ДcтАЛbd тАФ Shear strength of concrete section where ╧ДcтАЛ increases with axial compression.
The principal tensile stress ╧ГtтАЛ at any point in a structural element subjected to shear stress ╧Д and normal stress ╧ГxтАЛ (compression is negative) is given by Mohr's Circle analysis. When axial compression is present, it reduces the net tensile stress developed due to shear. By keeping the net principal tensile stress below the modulus of rupture of concrete, the initiation and propagation of diagonal tension cracks are significantly delayed or suppressed.
Diagonal tension is the result of inclined principal tensile stresses occurring at an angle to the beam axis.
Axial compression acts as a pre-stressing force that effectively 'closes' potential tension cracks.
In the presence of axial compression, the shear capacity of the section increases, requiring less transverse reinforcement.
The critical section for shear in such members is modified due to the presence of axial forces.
Enhanced resistance to shear cracking
Reduction in required shear reinforcement (stirrups)
Improved crack control and serviceability
May require larger section dimensions to accommodate axial force
Complexity in calculating net stress states
Prestressed concrete beams
Columns under combined axial load and shear
Bridge girders
Axial tension is detrimental as it adds to the tensile stress already induced by shear, thereby accelerating diagonal tension failure.
Option B (flexural and shear) is the standard state of a beam, but it does not intrinsically reduce diagonal tension compared to adding axial compression.
D is correct тАФ axial compression and shear force act simultaneously to reduce diagonal tension cracks.
Remember: Axial compression is beneficial for shear (improves capacity), while axial tension is harmful (reduces capacity) in R.C.C. members.